Fairywren Project

Late 2024 Update

 

Hi all, we're back with another update!

Allison and I recently attended the International Society for Behavioral Ecology meeting in Melbourne in October and while we saw exciting presentations on a variety of species and ideas, we were most excited to interact with and see the research from all the other fairywren researchers who attended. We named our project The Fairywren Project, but we’re hardly the only researchers studying fairywrens. Fairywrens are beloved by ornithologists and behavioral ecologists as much as they are by birders and we’re part of a long line of researchers attempting to better understand these charismatic species.

Many of the fairywren presentations we saw at the conference in Melbourne presented unpublished data, so we will not share those results with you yet, but in the meantime, 2024 has been a productive year already for fairywren research, so we’re going to highlight another recent paper that we think you might find interesting:

 

 

You might know Splendid Fairywrens from Mark Eatwell’s photographs, or hopefully from seeing them somewhere across their wide range. But did you realize there are four Splendid Fairywren subspecies?

 

Figure 1a from Kearns et al., 2024 showing the geographic boundaries of each subspecies. Photos are from the Macaulay Library at the Cornell Lab of Ornithology reproduced in Kearns et al.—M. s. splendens (ML611751385; Gosnells, Western Australia), M. s. callainus (ML519296141; Gawler Ranges, South Australia), M. s. melanotus (ML481245791; Mildura, Victoria), M. s. emmottorum (ML246987571; Barcoo, Queensland).

 

Three of these subspecies have limited contact in modern times and they look quite different, so taxonomists have wondered for a while whether these are true subspecies or whether splendens, callainus, and the combined melanotus and emmottorum group are best described as three separate species. The recent paper by Kearns et al., provides an answer to that question.

The authors compared the nuclear DNA of all four subspecies, and the best supported population structure model suggested three distinct genetic clusters. Importantly, this test did not include any information about geography – it only included genetic data – but the suggested genetic clusters matched up very well to the three subspecies groups. Based on these findings along with very careful analysis of the plumages and distributions of these subspecies from Fairywren Project collaborator Andrew Black and colleagues (read Black et al., 2022 here, read Black et al., 2023 here), Kearns et al. suggest the three Splendid subspecies groups (splendens, callainus, and the combination of melanotus and emmottorum) should be recognized as separate species.

 

What does this mean for you? Will the Splendid Fairywren soon be split into three separate species? Will your local Splendid Fairywren subspecies have its name changed? At the Fairywren Project, our protocol is to wait for the experts to decide (taxonomy is not our field of expertise). The process often looks something like this: step 1 – researchers investigate whether genetic and phenotypic evidence supports the separation of subspecies into separate species and publish their findings in a scientific journal article. Step 2 – a regional review board composed of taxonomists and ornithologists reviews the evidence for and against a split, then makes a decision. 3 – eBird adopts the change proposed by the review board, then the Clements/eBird taxonomy is updated to reflect the change. 4 – Following eBird, the Fairywren Project adopts the change.

The 2024 Clements/eBird update occurs once per year and just finished a few days ago (2 Nov 2024). That means the earliest a Splendid Fairywren split could occur in eBird would be around this time next year (2025). Until then, we’ll follow eBird’s lead and consider the Splendid Fairywren to be one species. But if you want to get ahead of the game and see all of the subspecies, you might get what’s called an “armchair” species for your life list if the split eventually occurs. You’ll be at home, maybe sitting in your armchair when the taxonomy update drops, and suddenly you’ll have a new species!

 

Read the article here: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/01584197.2024.2352400

A previous version of this study asked the same question using mitochondrial DNA. You can read that study here: https://nsojournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1111/j.1600-048X.2008.04383.x

 

Citations:

Black, A., Horton, P., Johnston, G., & Blaylock, B. (2022). Phenotypic separation of three divergent taxa within the Splendid Fairywren Malurus splendens. South Australian Ornithologist47(1), 38-43.

Black, A., Horton, P., Johnston, G., & Blaylock, B. (2023). What is the evidence of contact and interaction between the two divergent lineages of Splendid Fairywren Malurus splendens in South Australia?. South Australian Ornithologist47(2).

Kearns, A. M., Dolman, G., & Joseph, L. (2024). Does nuclear DNA support the recognition of three species within the Splendid Fairywren Malurus splendens?. Emu-Austral Ornithology, 1-8.

 

As always, thank you for your observations! We're working on your data and have some exciting papers in the works.

Joe and Allison

 

P.S. Be sure to either use our plumage codes: b (bright male), i (intermediate male), d (dull male), u (dull, unknown sex), f (female), j (juvenile), or use descriptions we can easily interpret like "male in breeding colors". Reporting you observed 2 males doesn't provide us with information we can use since there are so many male plumage types.

 

 

Posted by Fairywren Project

Mid 2024 Update

 

Hi friends,

We’re back with another research update! Scroll down for the latest project numbers, but first we’re highlighting some recent fairywren research that we were not involved in, but that we’re really excited about.

 

The evolutionary history of White-winged Fairywrens

Have you seen a White-winged Fairywren? They’re one of our favorite fairywrens, maybe because they often take a bit of work to find but are always worth the effort. If you live on the west coast, you might see them often, but if you live out east, you’ll likely have to go for a bit of a drive to reach their habitat.

You’re likely familiar with the blue-and-white males of mainland Australia, but did you know there are three White-winged Fairywren subspecies? The blue-and-white subspecies you might have seen ranges over most of Australia, but off the west coast you’ll find Dirk Hartog Island and Barrow Island that have black-and-white males.

 

Left – drawing of a bright male of the mainland blue-and-white subspecies (Malurus leucopterus leuconotus). Right – drawing of a bright male representative of the two black-and-white subspecies, Malurus leucopterus leucopterus on Dirk Hartog Island, and Malurus leucopterus edouardi on Barrow island.

 

The big question for fairywren researchers has always been: which came first? Did the black-and-white plumage evolve from the blue-and-white plumage? Or did the blue-and-white plumage evolve from the black-and-white plumage?

Answering this question has become much more approachable with modern genomic techniques. Researchers can now sequence an individual bird’s entire genome from a small blood sample. If you sequence the genomes of multiple individuals from different subspecies, then you can start to understand which subspecies evolved first. A recent scientific paper does this for the White-winged Fairywrens.

 

 

Simon Sin and colleagues (including a few Fairywren Project collaborators) first confirmed what previous research had already shown – that the two black-and-white populations on the separate islands are separate subspecies, and that the black-and-white subspecies evolved separately and are not each other’s closest relatives. From here, there are two options.

Hypothesis A: the blue-and-white mainland subspecies independently colonized the two islands, and black plumage evolved separately on each island. This independent evolution of the same or similar trait is called convergent evolution.

Hypothesis B: the blue-and-white mainland subspecies was once black-and-white. Then after colonizing each island, the mainland subspecies evolved the blue-and-white plumage. The figure below from the paper shows these two hypotheses:

 

Figure 2A from Sin et al., 2024.

 

To test between these hypotheses, Sin and colleagues first compared the genomes of black-and-white and blue-and-white individuals and found many genes that differed between the plumage types. Some of these genes had known functions identified in previous research, and one of them in particular stood out. Agouti signaling protein (ASIP) is associated with the distribution of melanin (brown and black pigments) in the body and the DNA sequences coding this gene showed major differences between the blue-and-white and black-and-white subspecies. Bingo!

Variation in this melanin-producing gene likely explains some of the plumage differences between the subspecies, but which plumage type came first? Next, the researchers looked for what are known as ‘selective sweeps’ in the DNA of the genes that differed between the subspecies. Selective sweep refers to the process by which new beneficial mutations become fixed in a population, and in doing so, sweep, or bring along the genes around them in the DNA sequence.

For example, imagine a random mutation in the DNA coding the ASIP gene leads a normally black-and-white fairywren to produce blue plumage. If females prefer to mate with the blue-and-white male rather than the black-and-white males, the blue-and-white male will produce more offspring than the average black-and-white male and the blue-and-white male’s offspring will likely carry the blue-and-white version of the gene. The sweep part occurs when recombination – the shuffling of genes between chromosomes when sperm and eggs are formed – is decreased in the region of the newly beneficial gene. If recombination results in a reversion of the ASIP gene to the black-and-white form, the resulting male offspring will sire fewer offspring because females prefer the blue-and-white males. This selection against recombination in one gene often results in nearby genes coming along for the ride – being swept up. Thus, a grouping of unshuffled genes around a gene of interest, like ASIP, indicates a recent beneficial mutation.

When Sin and colleagues looked for selective sweeps around the ASIP gene in the black-and-white and blue-and-white subspecies, they actually found it in the mainland blue-and-white subspecies. Since selective sweeps indicate a recent beneficial mutation, this finding indicates that the mainland blue-and-white subspecies evolved more recently, showing support for hypothesis B! Sin et al. conclude that the mainland White-winged Fairywrens were once black-and-white, but they have since evolved the blue-and-white plumage due to females preferring the blue-and-white males.

So next time you see a blue-and-white, White-winged Fairywren, imagine it as black and white, then remember how lucky we are to have both forms!

 

You can read the scientific paper for yourself here: https://academic.oup.com/mbe/article/41/3/msae046/7615515

Sin, S. Y. W., Ke, F., Chen, G., Huang, P. Y., Enbody, E. D., Karubian, J., ... & Edwards, S. V. (2024). Genetic basis and evolution of structural color polymorphism in an Australian songbird. Molecular Biology and Evolution41(3), msae046.

 

Want more info on the genomics parts of this story? Wikipedia has a great figure of how selective sweeps work:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Selective_sweep#/media/File:HardSelectiveSweep.jpg

And the University of Utah has a great primer on genetic recombination:

https://learn.genetics.utah.edu/content/pigeons/geneticlinkage/

 

Until next time,

Joe and Allison

 

 

 

 

Posted by Fairywren Project

Late 2023 Update

Hi all,

We’re back with another update! This time we have some preliminary results from the plumage data you’ve been sending us for the past five(!) years.

One of the fairywren traits we’re interested in is year-round ornamented (bright) plumage. Fairywrens moult or replace their body feathers twice per year. Males typically moult into a dull brown, non-breeding plumage at the end of the breeding season, then moult back into their ornamented breeding plumage prior to the beginning of the next breeding season.

However, male Lovely Fairywrens keep their ornamented breeding plumage year-round and old males from other species are known to remain in ornamented plumage year-round.

 

 

Previous research from Andrew Cockburn’s group in Canberra shows that old male Superb Fairywrens can remain in ornamented plumage year-round and that early-moulting males sire more offspring than males that moult into ornamented plumage late in the non-breeding season. This suggests that females pay attention to when males moult, likely because male fairywrens begin courting females as soon as they acquire ornamented plumage. However, early-moulting males suffer disproportionate mortality over late-moulting males, suggesting that early moult into ornamented plumage is likely costly for survival.

 

A male Superb Fairywren in ornamented plumage (middle) courting a female on the viewer’s left.

 

But, while we know this year-round plumage trait can occur, we don’t know how common it is across other populations. That is where your data come in!

Our questions is: how common is year-round ornamented plumage?

To start, we’re focusing on the species we have the most data on, the Superb Fairywren.

 

 

The map above shows 20 major populations of Superb Fairywrens we’ve identified in your sightings that cover most of the species’ range.

We’ve split the first four years of your data in to four yearly periods extending from August to July, then we split each year into 15-day intervals. For example, the plot below shows the number of birds seen in 15-day intervals from August 2020 to May 2021 in the population to the southeast of Melbourne in the map above (blue dot).

 

 

Then for each of these periods, we counted how many individual Superb Fairywrens of each plumage type were reported and converted these to percentages for each 15-day period (plot below).

 

 

You can see for this population near Melbourne in March and April 2021 (days 240-284), no males in ornamented plumage were reported even though 134 Superb Fairywrens were seen over a 45-day period! This suggests that year-round ornamented plumage did not occur in this population in that year, or that it was so rare that it was not detected.

Now we’re repeating this process for all 20 populations across the species range and comparing the presence and absence of year-round ornamented plumage to weather conditions. We’ll keep you updated as we learn more. In the meantime, keep letting us know what plumage types you’re seeing!

As always, thank you for all your effort so far. We’re really excited about these data.

Joe and Allison

 

Below you'll find the newest numbers for the project:

 

 

 

 

Posted by Fairywren Project

We’re recruiting!

 

 

We have big news: we're recruiting! We recently received funding from the National Science Foundation (US) and we're now looking for a PhD student to join our project. Please see the letter from Allison below:

Dai Shizuka and I are recruiting a graduate student to start in Fall 2024 on our NSF funded project on the ecogeography of social behavior in Australian birds. The student would be joining Dai’s lab at University of Nebraska-Lincoln but would be doing fieldwork with me (PI of the grant and Research Assistant Professor associated with the Shizuka Lab) on fairywrens. The deadline for applications to UNL is December 1st, but we highly encourage the student to contact us as soon as possible so we can have a chance to correspond and potentially meet via Zoom.

The student would be engaged in studies of avian social behavior along an ecological gradient across south-eastern Australia, with the potential to additionally work on mixed-species flock studies and long-term field studies at Brookfield Conservation Park, SA. Below we’ve included a brief description of the primary intended research. Please encourage any students to email both myself (ajohnson165@unl.edu) and Dr. Shizuka (dshizuka2@unl.edu) as I’m currently in the field and may have limited ability to respond quickly.

Project Overview: 

This project develops an ecogeographic approach to understand the processes that generate both within- and across-species variation in structure of cooperative social groups across environmental gradients. We suggest that integrating ecogeographic patterns across two levels of biological organization, within and across species, will provide new information about how cooperative groups evolve. Such an approach can simultaneously address whether social systems respond to environmental gradients and why species may respond differently from one another. We will accomplish this through three aims: 1) develop a theoretical framework for understanding how environmental effects on social dynamics may generate variation in group structure across environmental gradients, 2) use a cross-continental citizen science dataset on Australian fairywrens (Aves, Maluridae) to examine ecogeographic patterns in social group size across all species and investigate how factors such as urbanization or interacting climate variables alter environment-group size relationships, and 3) conduct observational and experimental studies in two fairywren species to explicitly link disparate patterns of variation to changes in fitness and behavior. The broader impacts activities include a major citizen science platform deployed in collaboration with eBird, and professionally developed high-impact interdisciplinary lesson plans targeting middle school students.

Sincerely

Allison Johnson

Posted by Fairywren Project

Mid 2023 Update

Hi all,

We're a bit late in posting this. If you want these early, join our email list!

New numbers are in and we have a new paper published! On the numbers front we’re getting close to over 20,000 eBird checklists with plumage and/or group data. We just presented some analyses on these data at the annual American Ornithological Society conference earlier in August and we’ll update you with those results in our next update coming in October. In the meantime, here’s a rundown of our new paper:

 

Ecogeography of group size suggests differences in drivers of sociality among cooperatively breeding fairywrens

Photo by Sandra Gallienne via eBird (https://macaulaylibrary.org/asset/86886001)

 

Back in 2018 when Allison and I started the Fairywren Project, we decided it would be useful to supplement the continent-wide data you’re submitting through eBird with a few focused transects across an environment gradient. That led to two trips where we traveled from wet, coastal Victoria, north to dry, arid Broken Hill in New South Wales. Along the way we recorded data on group sizes and plumage types.

 

Average annual rainfall in Australia from 1989 to 2019. Points represent locations where social groups were observed. Circles are purple-backed fairywren populations and triangles are superb fairywren populations.

 

Our initial targets during the first transect in 2018 were Purple-backed Fairywrens and White-winged Fairywrens. But as we started, we ran into many Superb Fairywrens, and the White-wings turned out to be much harder to track down than we expected. They are one of our favorite species but we’re constantly amazed and often frustrated by the way a group of White-winged Fairywrens can disappear into the underbrush then reappear 50 meters away in what feels like seconds. Tracking them consistently was going to require more time than we had available.

 

Above: often the typical viewing distance for White-winged Fairywrens. Below: A bright male Purple-backed Fairywren who was more interested in foraging than in me and my camera.

 

But both Superb Fairywrens and Purple-backed Fairywrens typically let us get very close for detailed observations of plumages and group sizes. When we came back for the second transect in 2019, we focused entirely on these species. What we found was really interesting!

But first some background: Both species are cooperative breeders, meaning breeding male and female pairs are often joined by additional individuals (helpers) that assist the pair in nest defense and raising offspring. In Purple-backed Fairywrens, breeding pairs with helpers raise more offspring than pairs without helpers, suggesting helpers contribute to nesting success. But in Superb Fairywrens, helpers do not appear to influence nesting success and helping behavior appears to be driven by a lack of suitable breeding territories for young males to disperse into. When a breeding territory does open up, these helper males immediately disperse and the breeding pair can usually raise offspring just fine on their own.

Species that gain reproductive benefits from cooperative breeding, like Purple-backed Fairywrens, tend to occur in harsh, arid environments, likely due to the benefits that cooperative breeding confers when food is limited. Nestling songbirds like fairywrens are dependent on their parents to bring them food, so the more individuals feeding offspring, the more food those offspring are going to receive, and the more likely they will survive.

On the other hand, species that are primarily cooperative due to a saturation of breeding territories, like Superb Fairywrens, tend to occur in mild, wet environments. These productive environments likely have much more abundant and predictable insect prey than harsh, arid environments like the Outback, meaning helpers are not typically needed to raise offspring.

 

Left: Allison in Greater Bendigo National Park, Victoria. Right: Allison outside of Broken Hill.

 

But we know little about how species respond to environmental variation across their range. Is cooperative breeding behavior fixed within each species? Or does this behavior change in response to environmental conditions? Both Purple-backed and Superb Fairywrens experience substantial environmental variation across their ranges, with Purple-backed Fairywrens ranging over nearly all of Australia and Superb Fairywrens ranging from the eastern and south-eastern coasts all the way up to the edge of the Outback.

 

 

Our question was:

How do different environments influence cooperative breeding behavior in Purple-backed and Superb Fairywrens, and do these species respond to environmental variation in the same way?

We found that both species exhibited variation in group size across our environmental gradient, but they responded to environmental variation in different ways. Purple-backed Fairywrens exhibited small group sizes in wet habitats and large group sizes in dry habitats, whereas Superb Fairywrens showed the opposite trend. See the figure below.

 

 

These results show that a species’ cooperative breeding behavior can respond to environmental conditions and shows that how a species responds is likely shaped by the costs and benefits the species gains from cooperative breeding. For Purple-backed Fairywrens, forming large social groups with many helpers in harsh habitats is likely beneficial for nesting success when food is unpredictable. However, when they occur in wet, mild habitats where food may be more abundant, they don’t need as many helpers to raise offspring.

But Superb Fairywrens appear to mainly form large social groups in wet, mild habitats with abundant food. When we found Superb Fairywrens on the edge of the Outback, they were almost always in pairs and were widely distributed, not clumped together like on the coast, implying that young males have plenty of opportunities to disperse in those regions dominated by harsh habitats and possibly lower nesting success.

Despite the group size trend, we found pairs of both species in nearly every habitat we visited. That’s not too surprising because most fairywren helpers are offspring from previous breeding attempts, meaning large groups can only form if a pair first reproduces on their own, resulting in most populations consisting of a mix of group sizes, including many pairs.

These findings are interesting because they show that cooperative behavior can vary quite a bit within a species in response to local environmental conditions. That means that the Superb Fairywren group sizes you see in your in your garden or local park may be quite different from the group sizes that someone else sees at the other end of the species’ range. These adaptations to different environments can help us understand how species like Purple-backed Fairywrens are able to inhabit most of Australia.

We’re currently working to answer these same questions in the data you’ve been sending. For example, do Superb Fairywrens exhibit this same pattern in relation to rainfall across their entire range? Keep submitting data when you can! We will update you with some of our initial findings later this year.

And thank you for all the data you’ve submitted already! We’re creating quite a database that will be extremely valuable to understanding questions like these on a very broad scale.

Joe and Allison

Read the full paper here.

 

Posted by Fairywren Project

Early 2023 Update

 

Hi all,

We’re back with another update! We have new numbers for you below and we’re hard at work investigating our first research questions using the data you’ve been submitting. We do not have any results ready to present yet, but in the meantime we thought we would provide a brief overview of a paper on Red-backed Fairywrens that Joe recently published from work completed during his PhD.

Photoperiod and rainfall are associated with seasonal shifts in social structure in a songbird:

 

 

You may have noticed in your own observations that the fairywrens near you behave differently in the spring and summer versus fall and winter seasons. Some of the reasons for these differences are obvious – in the spring and summer when fairywrens breed, they need to build nests and defend territories. These breeding territories function as a foraging area where a breeding group can find plenty of food and as a way for males to prevent other males from mating with their female.

However, in the winter, this defending of territories is often not necessary. This is especially true for Red-backed Fairywrens. While they breed primarily in pairs and sometimes have sons that help their parents at the nest, during the winter they can form large foraging flocks. Some previous reports suggest these flock sizes can get over 30 birds!

In this study, we wanted to understand when this transition from a flocking, non-breeding social structure to a territorial breeding social structure occurs, and specifically what environmental variables (such as temperature or rainfall) were associated with when this transition occurs.

My teams and I (Joe) followed groups and flocks of Red-backed Fairywrens during part of the non-breeding season (June-August) in eastern Queensland, just outside of Brisbane for four years. All of the individuals in our population at this time had color bands on their legs (see photo above), allowing us to identify unique individuals during our observations.

From these observations we were able to create a social network – a visual representation of social relationships:

 

 

Each point represents an individual bird that we followed for multiple months and the color and shape of the point conveys information on sex and status. Previous breeders are older birds who bred in the previous breeding season, while helpers and young birds are typically only 6-8 months old, having hatched in the previous breeding season. Lines connecting points show which individuals interacted with one another and thicker lines show individuals that interacted more often with one another than individuals connected by thinner lines.

Immediately by looking at the thickness of the lines you can start to identify specific social groups. Black lines connect individuals in the same social group and gray lines connect individuals in separate social groups. Our observations revealed that Red-backed Fairywrens at our field site almost always traveled in social groups and that these social groups were typically family groups composed of parents and their offspring from the previous breeding season. The dotted gray lines show larger social communities composed of social groups that interacted often.

Here's an example of what a social group can look like. I took this video just after arriving in Australia one year, so some of the birds do not have bands yet. The red-and-black (bright) individual is the male, the brown bird with the single band on each leg is the female and the other two brown birds are their two offspring from the previous breeding season.

 

 

So when you see flocks of Red-backed Fairywrens during the non-breeding season or winter, you’re likely seeing multiple social groups forming up together. Similar research from a group at Monash University indicates the same patterns occur in Superb Fairywrens down in Melbourne.

When we compared these interactions among social groups to environmental conditions, we found that rainfall is associated with interaction rates among social groups. Greater rainfall 1.5 - 2 months before an observation was associated with fewer interactions among social groups on that day. This likely means that Red-backed Fairywrens are responding physiologically to the effects of rainfall in the non-breeding season, such as greener vegetation and increased insect abundance, resulting in changes in their social behavior as they become more and more territorial as the breeding season approaches.

If you want to read the full paper you can download it here: LINK

Questions? Contact us! We’re always happy to chat: fairywrenproject@gmail.com

 

A note on data quality in your eBird observations:
Almost all of you are submitting observations that are easily interpretable and usable, but a few participants appear to be submitting plumage observations using only “male” and “female” codes. Male and female codes alone do not give us much information to work with because males can come in multiple plumage types (LINK). If you can, either use our suggested codes: bright (b), intermediate (i), dull (d), female (f), juvenile (j), or something similar that is easily interpretable for us. For example, if you say “moulting male” we know that’s an intermediate male, if you say “brown male” we know that’s a dull male.

Thanks!

Joe and Allison

 

Posted by Fairywren Project

Fairywren Project Update mid-2022

 

Hi all,

New Fairywren Project numbers are in! We're excited to see the project continuing to grow in participant and checklist numbers. Together we're building an incredible database that will help us understand how fairywrens respond to environmental variation. Analyses are currently underway to start answering some of these questions! Below is a quick summary of the next analyses we're working on:

Group size variation across environments
We previously published a pre-print (a pre-publication version of a paper) describing our findings of group size variation in Purple-backed and Superb Fairywrens from the transects we conducted at the beginning of this project. We recently received helpful reviews back on this paper and are now preparing to re-submit it for publication. Once that's complete we'll begin asking whether we see the same trends across more species in the continental data you're submitting.

Prevalence of year-round bright plumage
Most male fairywrens exhibit two plumages per year, a bright, nuptial plumage during the breeding season and a brown, female-like plumage during the non-breeding season or winter. However, in at least a few populations of a few species, old males are known to sometimes exhibit bright breeding plumage year-round. Females pay attention to when males moult into bright plumage and tend to mate with the males that moult the earliest, so these year-round bright males may experience a big advantage to retaining this fancy plumage all year. Soon we're going to be using your data to investigate how widespread this phenomenon is that is currently only known to occur in single populations from a few species.

Until next time, happy birding! Let us know if you have any questions.

Joe and Allison

 

 

Posted by Fairywren Project

Hybrid Fairywrens paper published!

Hi all,

We’re excited to announce that our first Fairywren Project paper is out! Working with photographers and birders from around the country, we described three new instances of hybridisation in fairywrens and provided more information on a previous report.

 

This was a really fun paper to write and something we didn’t expect to work on when we started the Fairywren Project. Thanks to Martin Ross for first alerting us to one of these hybrids!

You can view/download the paper here:
https://www.birdlife.org.au/afo/index.php/afo/article/view/2254

Also check out Martin Ross and Allan Briggs’ paper on the behaviour of some of the Red-backed x Superb Fairywren hybrids:
https://www.birdlife.org.au/afo/index.php/afo/article/view/2255

And see the updated hybrid fairywrens page on our website:
https://fairywrenproject.org/hybrid-fairywrens/

Want more fairywrens? Joe talked fairywrens with Grant Williams of the Bird Emergency podcast and Dr. Holly Parsons of Birdlife Australia on the BE podcast this past Monday. You can view the recording here:
https://thebirdemergency.com/the-fairywren-project/

If you’re interested in hearing more about the hybrids, Joe will be talking with Grant and Holly again on May 30th at 12pm Melbourne time. You can livestream it or find the recording on the Bird Emergency webpage when it comes out.

Happy birding!

Joe and Allison

Posted by Fairywren Project

Learn more about Purple-crowned Fairywrens!

 

 

Hi all,

The Australian Wildlife Conservancy (AWC) has recently released a webinar with two fairywren experts on the breeding biology of the Purple-crowned Fairywren. Dr. Anne Peters and Dr. Nikki Teunissen have been studying Purple-crowned Fairywrens at AWC’s Mornington Wildlife Sanctuary for many years and have discovered many insights into this species’ unique behavior. This is a fun conversation and an unprecedented opportunity to learn more about this species that few people have the opportunity to see. Follow the link below to hear from Dr. Peters, Dr. Teunissen, and the AWC:

AWC webinar link:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9jWJ2f-wZi8&t=1s

For more on their research see Dr. Peter’s website:
https://sites.google.com/site/petersresearchgroup/our-research

Above image by Nikki Teunissen.

Posted by Fairywren Project

A big Fairywren Project update for 2022

Hi friends of the Fairywren Project,

To our new followers, welcome! To our continuing followers, sorry it has taken so long to get an update to you! 2021 was a busy year. If you’re short on time we’ll summarize here and expand below:

Update summary:

The Fairywren Project is entering an exciting phase. We’re about 3.5 years old and you’ve submitted over 14,000 eBird checklists! We’re working on your checklist data but in the meantime, we have two research papers we’ve recently finished: one on hybridisation in Fairywrens, and another analyzing the group size data that Allison and I collected during our survey trips in 2018 and 2019. The hybrids paper should be published in the next month or two and the group size paper should hopefully come out in the next six months or so.

2021 was busy, plans for 2022:

I finished my PhD at the end of 2020, then Allison and I spent most of 2021 pursuing research grants to fund field work to supplement the data you are collecting. We see your data as representing the broad, continental patterns occurring in fairywren plumages and group sizes, then we’re hoping to eventually do more focused research that will help us uncover the mechanisms underlying the patterns that your data reveal. Receiving this extra funding is not required for the Fairywren Project to succeed, but it will give us an opportunity to connect the broad scale patterns you are helping to uncover to more fine-scale social processes. In the meantime, I accepted a postdoc position studying Mountain Chickadees in the Sierra Nevada mountains in the U.S. (read more on these fascinating birds here). I’ll be in this position for 2-4 years and during this time, Allison and I will continue our Fairywren Project work while balancing the work required of our research positions. We’re excited for what’s next!

Research coming out soon:

Hybridisation in Fairywrens – if you’re on our email list, you may have seen back in February of last year we sent out a call asking if anyone had ever seen a hybrid fairywren. As teased above in the summary, we’re excited to report that our paper in collaboration with photographers from across the country is now accepted for publication in Australian Field Ornithology, a scientific journal published by Birdlife Australia. This paper documents three new instances of hybridisation in fairywrens and provides further details on a previously-reported fourth instance. The paper should be available in the next month or two. We’ll send a link when it is published so you can learn more about this neat topic. We’ll also update the fairywren hybrids portion of our website at that time.

Group size variation in fairywrens in relation to environmental variation – if you’ve been with us since we launched the project, you might remember that back in 2018 and 2019 Allison and I traveled from southern Victoria north to Broken Hill, NSW, recording fairywren group sizes and plumages along the way. These two trips were our proof-of-concept trips where we were trying out the methods you are using to report group sizes and plumage data. We’re excited to say that these observations turned up some interesting patterns and we’ve now submitted a paper detailing these patterns.

Now that we’ve sent the paper to the journal, an editor at the journal will send the paper to two or three reviewers who will read the paper and give us comments back on it, including whether they agree with our interpretations of the data. This process often takes 2 months or longer, then based on the reviews we’ll have an opportunity to revise the paper and resubmit it. We’re hoping this publication should be out in six months or so. If you cannot wait and want to know the results right away, we’ve posted a pre-print online that you can check out here. This is a pre-publication version of the paper, so it will be revised once we receive reviews, but pre-prints are a common tool to get ideas out quickly, provide access to a wider audience, and get feedback on the research prior to publication.

Next research goals:

Group size variation in fairywrens using your data – our publication of our transect data is a small taste of the data you’ve been submitting on group sizes through your eBird checklists. One of our next projects is to see if the same trends we saw in our transect occur on a continent-wide scale using your checklist data, and to see how these trends vary across species. Allison is currently working on these analyses.

Prevalence of year-round bright plumage in fairywrens – most male fairywrens moult into dull (brown) plumage at the end of the breeding season, however, research by Ana Leitão and colleagues suggested that male Lovely Fairywrens keep bright plumage year-round. It is also recognized that in multiple other species of fairywrens, old males sometimes remain in ornamented plumage year-round, but it appears they are not able to do this for multiple years in a row. However, these observations only come from single study sites, or at most a few populations per species. One of the next questions we’re hoping to answer is: is year-round bright plumage a widespread phenomenon?

Based on previous research, we only expect a few males in each population to do this each year, but the data you’ve been submitting over the last couple years offer an incredible opportunity to answer this question. Just think if one researcher were to try to answer this question alone, it might make for a fun trip, but it would be impossible to visit as many populations as you have provided data on! Just look at the map below to see how extensive your data are. We expect that year-round bright plumage will be a widespread phenomenon, at least for a couple males in each population each year. However, if it’s not that will be a very interesting result too. Either way, we’re looking forward to seeing what your data show and we’ll keep you updated. And keep submitting data when you can! Observations you submit now through August 2022 (the approximate start of the next breeding season) will likely make it into the final version of this paper.

A further note on funding:

Sometimes participants ask us if they can contribute financially to the Fairywren Project. For those that have asked, thank you for your generosity. However, we always redirect these offers because we don’t think this is a project that can be supported by participant donations alone. Our primary source of support comes from large granting agencies.

Instead, if you want to contribute financially to bird research, consider donating to Birdlife Australia. They’re a great conservation and research organization and the number one advocate for birds in Australia. Also consider a project called Wing Threads, they are currently raising money through around March 8th to fund a ultralight trip around Australia highlighting the plight of shorebirds. For us, just send us your plumage and group size observations via eBird!

A note on data quality:

Almost all of you are submitting observations that are easily interpretable and high quality, but a few participants appear to be submitting plumage observations using only “male” and “female” codes. Male and female codes alone do not give us much information to work with because males can come in multiple plumage types. If you can, either use our suggested codes: bright (b), intermediate (i), dull (d), female (f), juvenile (j), or something similar that is easily interpretable for us. For example, if you say “moulting male” we know that’s an intermediate male, if you say “brown male” we know that’s a dull male. Thanks!

Thank you to everyone who has contributed! Please let us know if you have any questions via fairywrenproject@gmail.com. Look for the link to the paper on hybridisation in fairywrens soon and until then, happy birding!

Joe and Allison

P.S. We hope you're all safe despite the crazy floods on the east coast.

 

 

Posted by Fairywren Project